Yvonne Williams

№004

You’re not busy. You’re overstimulated.

, 4 min read

My children ask to be stimulated when they are ‘bored’...

Not in those words. They ask for the iPad, the telly, the phone, something, anything, and they ask within about four minutes of having “nothing to do”.

As a family we now keep Sundays screen free, and the first hour of a screen-free Sunday is not peaceful. It is a negotiation.

Here is the part that should bother you. You do the same thing. You are just better dressed about it.

The phone in the lift. The podcast in the car. The inbox between two meetings that are already back to back. You have not left a gap in your day in years, and you think of that as being busy. I would call it something else.

When did you last sit in a room and do nothing on purpose?

Not a holiday. Not a long flight with the laptop out. Nothing.

Most of the leaders I work with cannot answer it. When I ask it, the answer usually arrives as a reason why the question does not apply.

My mother’s two hours

When I was off school, my mother would get me started on something. She assumed it would hold me for an hour, and then she would say: don’t come back for two hours.

Two hours. No instructions for the second hour.

And she used to say this, which I did not understand at all at the time: it’s okay to just sit and be quiet and still and listen to the silence.

I understand it now. I sit and listen to the silence often. I let my thoughts wander, and sometimes I deliberately bring them back to nothing at all, which is harder than it sounds and worth more than it sounds. She was handing us two hours in which nobody was going to tell us what to do, and we had to work out for ourselves what we did with them. I only see that now.

Nobody has handed you two hours in a very long time. And you would give them back.

What the research actually says, and where it argues with itself

This is where I have to be straight with you, because the science here is messier than the headlines.

Ask a man how boredom feels and he will tell you flat, low, switched off. Measure him and the picture is less obvious. A team who reviewed the whole field concluded that much, though not all, of the research suggests boredom is a high arousal state, and that what people report feeling and what their body is actually doing often fail to match. Closer to revving than to resting.

So boredom is not a nice quiet state I am recommending to you. It is uncomfortable, and the discomfort is the whole point.

One way to understand it, argued by the psychologist James Danckert and his colleagues, is that boredom is a signal, and they compare it to pain. Pain tells you something needs a response. Boredom tells you your attention is not engaged and something has to change. In itself it carries no verdict on you. It is information arriving.

Which means a man who has removed every gap from his day has not solved boredom. He has stopped receiving the message. The signal is still being sent. There is simply never a quiet enough moment to hear it.

Where you will feel this, before you think it

The hand that reaches for the phone before you decided to. The leg going under the table. The jaw. The three seconds of quiet at a red light that you fill without noticing you filled it.

That reach is the gap closing. You can feel it happen if you are watching for it, and you can usually feel it a second or two before you can stop it.

Capacity is the ability to move through every state your nervous system goes into and come back to steady. You cannot practise coming back to steady in a day with no gaps in it. There is nowhere for it to happen.

The other thing boredom gave me

Years of sitting in the quiet taught me something I did not expect, and it is the reason I am writing to you about this at all.

Boredom taught me what actually captures my attention.

You only find that out by contrast. If you are never without stimulation, every single thing in your day holds your attention about equally, because something is always arriving. Take the input away and the difference shows up immediately: there are things you return to when nobody is making you, and things you have been doing for years out of pure momentum.

You cannot know what holds you if you are never without it.

One thing to try before Monday

Ten minutes, once, with nothing. No phone, no music, no notebook, no dog.

Watch for the moment you reach for something, and notice how long it takes for the reaching to settle down. There is nothing to achieve in the ten minutes.

The first few minutes are usually the unpleasant ones. That is the signal arriving. It has been trying to get through for a while.

Next week: why an ordinary day with nothing dramatic in it still leaves you wrung out by six, and what your body does every time something pings.

Mind how you go.

Yvonne

Get the next one on Monday

One letter every Monday at 7am. About five minutes. Letter readers hear it first.

The Altitude Retreat: twenty-four hours in the Lake DistrictThe retreat · Terms · Privacy